For the past several years, Housing First Minnesota has been working on the issue of building permit overcharging in many Minnesota communities.
In reviews of public data self-reported by cities and in city financial records, Housing First Minnesota has consistently see clear evidence that homebuyers are being overcharged for building permits in many growing communities.
On July 26, Housing First Minnesota initiated lawsuits against the cities of Corcoran and Dayton in Hennepin County District Court over their disproportionate building permit fees, which are contrary to state law.
These two cities have self-reported a combined $5.5 million surplus in collected permit fees in recent years. These lawsuits come after an administrative panel with the Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry declined to hear the matter, stating that it did not have oversight over this challenge.
In its past correspondence to these cities, Housing First Minnesota detailed how the cities were overcharging for building permits, asked that building permit fees be brought in line with state law, and demanded that surpluses be refunded to homebuyers.
Housing First Minnesota’s executive director, David Siegel, issues the following statement regarding the lawsuits initiated today:
“While excessive permit fees are not the largest barrier behind our region’s soaring housing costs, they are one of the most solvable issues to address in order to bring down the cost of housing in our state. The lawsuits initiated by Housing First Minnesota are necessary as cities have continued to overcharge homebuyers in conflict with state law even after they have been directed to comply.”
Background
Under Minnesota law, building permit fees “must be by legal means and must be fair, reasonable, and proportionate to the actual cost of the service for which the fee is imposed.”
The Minnesota Department of Labor and Industry has explicitly stated to local governments that building permit fees cannot be used to bolster the city’s general revenue fund or for special purpose projects. Documents obtained from both Corcoran and Dayton confirm the unauthorized use of building permit funds.
Following a review of public data, Housing First Minnesota found that many metro cities overcharge for new building permits. Housing First Minnesota sent a letter in December to several metro cities demanding that their permit fees be brought into compliance with state law. The filing of the lawsuits follows several attempts to have these cities reform their permit fee structures to comply with state law and Department of Labor guidance.
While Corcoran and Dayton are the only cities named in the current lawsuits, they are not the only Minnesota municipalities currently overcharging for building permit surpluses.
Download the Corcoran Complaint.
Download the Dayton Complaint.
Follow our advocacy team on Twitter for frequent updates and to stay engaged.
